海角论坛

Election integrity, misinformation center stage at Town Hall

By Samantha Herndon Wednesday, September 25, 2024

Speaking to a crowd of about 300 at Town Hall Seattle, Emma S. Spiro noted the many changes as well as familiar patterns that she and her colleagues at the University of Washington have researched in the five years since the CIP鈥檚 founding. 

The Sept. 11 conversation on Town Hall鈥檚 Great Hall stage focused on research, reflections and dialogue on rumors, mis- and disinformation, and different ways of  topics related to election integrity. Spiro, associate professor at the Information School and incoming CIP faculty director, was joined in conversation by Sarah Nguy峄卬, Ph.D. candidate at the Information School; Kate Starbird, CIP co-founder and outgoing director and professor of Human Centered Design & Engineering; and NPR correspondent Shannon Bond. 

The mission of the Center for an Informed Public (CIP) is to resist strategic misinformation, promote an informed society, and strengthen democratic discourse. The CIP is one of the multidisciplinary research centers affiliated with the University of Washington Information School. 

The CIP defines rumors as 鈥渦nverified or contested claims or stories spreading through informal channels,鈥 and the center鈥檚 new series 鈥溾 details phases of elections, including those with an increased prevalence of rumoring. 

During the discussion at Town Hall, held in collaboration with KUOW and KNKX public media, Nguy峄卬 (pictured at top right) spoke about her doctoral research, including work studying the spread of information in Vietnamese American communities. One group she has worked with are Vietnamese American elders, who are often underserved by traditional news media. Without reliable information translated into their mother tongue, and with less familiarity with deepfakes, algorithms and other technologies, this group could be vulnerable to scams and misinformation, she said. 

Nguy峄卬 and Spiro discussed the importance of approaching this research with a participatory model. Nguy峄卬 designed  to engage the community, rather than studying them from a distance. She connected with a group of elders who have been meeting weekly for the past 50 years. Despite their initial hesitation, Nguy峄卬 was able to explore research questions with them, such as 鈥淗ow do you share information? What makes you trust information?鈥 And, 鈥淗ow do you receive information?鈥 

In a humorous anecdote, Nguy峄卬 told a story about how doing karaoke with research participants helped them to build trust and community across a generational divide. Nguy峄卬 and Spiro also spoke about the ways in which some politicians have exploited this group of elders鈥 fears and lingering trauma from the Vietnam War, known in Vietnam as 鈥渢he American War,鈥 such as concerns about communism, funding for militarization abroad, and national division. This research will inform her dissertation, currently titled 鈥淪haring Stories, Sharing Trust: Making sense of transnational information and diasporic memories.鈥

Shannon Bond of NPR and Kate Starbird of the Center for an Informed Public, seated on stage under a screen reading "protecting election integrity with NPR's Shannon Bond."
NPR's Shannon Bond (left) and Professor Kate Starbird share the stage for a discussion about election mis- and disinformation on Sept. 11 at Town Hall Seattle.

鈥淪tudents like Sarah Nguy峄卬 shape how we do our work鈥 at the CIP, Starbird said. Sharing the stage with NPR鈥檚 Bond, the often-interviewed Starbird had the chance to turn the table and interview the media correspondent. Starbird and Bond discussed the key role that vetted journalism plays in addressing misinformation, the challenges of shifting and charged terminology, and the current landscape in which rumors can spread rapidly.

Given the highly politicized nature of the terms 鈥渕isinformation,鈥 鈥渄isinformation,鈥 and the previously common 鈥渇ake news,鈥 Starbird noted that she and her colleagues have found 鈥渞umor鈥 to be a more useful term. Rumors, she noted, sometimes do turn out to be true. Savvy creators produce content to fit certain pre-existing frames, Starbird said, such as border crises and a rigged election.

鈥淒isinformation is not a piece of content,鈥 Starbird noted. 鈥淚t鈥檚 a campaign.鈥 Bond and Starbird discussed the use of influencers to spread information, including the recent Department of Justice investigation into . Compared to bots, influencers are fairly cost effective for those who wish to reach large audiences, Starbird said. 

Bond and Starbird compared challenges for journalists and academic researchers in monitoring constantly changing online information, particularly in an election year. They noted that data that was previously free to access on Twitter now costs hundreds of thousands of dollars to access on X. The lack of transparency and reduced content moderation can make it easier for disinformation campaigns to thrive in the current context, but new research methods can be applied.

鈥淚鈥檓 still hopeful, and I do see signs of change,鈥 Starbird told Bond. Working with a dedicated team of researchers, including graduate researchers such as Nguy峄卬, can make this challenging work more manageable and enjoyable.

After publishing several academic papers on her research, Nguy峄卬 decided to share her work in a way that is more accessible to a larger audience. The CIP and Nguy峄卬 published "," an illustrated booklet in Vietnamese and English that synthesizes research findings into a fictional narrative. This work was created in collaboration with CIP Research Scientist and Information School Affiliate Assistant Professor Rachel Moran-Prestridge, UW Honors undergraduate student Celestine Le, UW Fine Arts alum and graphic artist Anh Nguyen, and translator Trung Anh Nguyen. You can read "" online to learn more about this research, and follow the .